Saving vs. Investing: 2 Ways to Reach Your Financial Goals | Stash Learn
Saving vs. investing: 2 ways to reach your financial goals
By: Sarah Spagnolo
Published: May 28, 2024 • Updated: Aug 27, 2024
Saving and investing are different—and each serves a unique purpose in a financial plan. When you learn the distinction, you can plan with more confidence.
In this article:
- The key differences between saving and investing
- When to save your money
- When to invest your money
- Saving vs. investing: strike the balance you need for financial security
When you’re mapping out a plan to reach your financial goals, you don’t have to choose just one path. It’s not about whether saving or investing is the better choice, but rather understanding the unique ways both saving and investing play crucial roles in working toward your financial aspirations. While saving often involves setting aside money for an emergency fund or a specific short-term goal like buying a new car, investing is a long-term strategy that helps your money grow over time by generating returns. Investing money and building up your cash savings are both valuable ways to ensure your financial needs are met now and far into the future.
| What’s the difference between saving and investing? Savings are designated for short-term financial goals or emergency funds and kept in a savings account at a bank or credit union. People often save the money they have left over after covering their monthly expenses. On the other hand, investing involves purchasing assets like stocks, bonds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), or mutual funds to earn returns. People generally invest with the hope of reaching long-term goals and earning more money over time than they would if they put the same amount of money into a savings account. |
|---|
The key differences between saving and investing
Saving and investing are distinct financial concepts. While they both involve putting money toward the goal of increasing your assets in the future, they have very different functions and results when it comes to time horizon, potential for returns, liquidity, risk, and inflation. Once you understand the differences, you can determine how each fits into your financial plan.
| Saving | Investing | |
|---|---|---|
| Time horizon | Short-term goals (5 years or less) | Mid- to long-term goals (5+ years to several decades) |
| Returns | Lower, based on typical savings account interest rates | Higher, depending on asset and market performance |
| Liquidity | Highly liquid, few limitations | Less liquid, more limitations |
| Associated risk | Relatively low risk | Higher risk |
| Impact of inflation | May eat away at the future value of your money | Returns often outpace inflation rates |
Your future goals
Some of your future financial goals are achievable sooner than others. If you’re looking at the short term, think of savings. If your goal is further into the future, consider investing.
Short-term goals: Saving can be a good choice for achieving short-term financial goals like taking a vacation, buying a car, getting a new computer, or putting a down payment on a home. Opening a savings account is also ideal for building up an emergency fund to cover large, unexpected expenses or get you by if you lose your job.
Long-term goals: In contrast, investing is more appropriate for achieving large goals far in the future, like paying for your kid’s college education or setting yourself up for retirement. Investments have the potential to grow your money more over time by earning higher returns than you’d get from earning interest in a savings account, but you may need to keep your money invested over the long haul to realize those gains.
Potential returns
The return on investment (ROI) differs quite a bit between saving vs. investing. The entire point of investing is to earn returns. Saving is more about setting aside money over time, but earning interest in a savings account certainly does grow your money more than hiding it in your mattress. Most traditional savings accounts pay some interest, and you can often earn an even better rate with high-yield savings accounts, money market accounts, and certificates of deposit (CDs). Interest rates are variable, and often rise and fall in relation to inflation. The longer you keep your savings in an interest-bearing account, the more you can take advantage of compound interest, which is when the interest you’ve earned also earns interest.
The ROI on different types of investments can vary greatly, but over the long term they usually outpace both inflation and what you could earn through interest in a bank account. The historical average return for stocks is around 10%, while bonds have historically produced 5% to 6% in returns on average. Other investment vehicles like mutual funds, index funds, and ETFs vary quite a bit in their average returns, since each fund contains a different mix of multiple assets. But because they usually hold stocks and bonds, funds tend to offer more lucrative long-term returns than a simple savings account.
Impact of inflation
Inflation measures how much the cost of products and services rise over a given period of time. When inflation goes up, your purchasing power goes down; your dollars don’t go as far as they used to. This is an important consideration for your savings. If the interest rate on your savings account is lower than the inflation rate, it erodes the value of your savings over time.
The money you earn today will have less purchasing power in a couple decades, so you want your investments to generate enough returns to compensate. Investing is often used as a hedge against inflation because the returns are generally higher than inflation over the long term. That’s why investing is important and typically advised for financial goals far into the future, like retirement. In fact, some investors pursue strategies intended specifically to profit from inflation.
Liquidity (how accessible your money is to you)
Liquidity describes how quickly you can get your hands on your money. Cash is your most liquid asset; actual dollar bills in your wallet can be spent any time. Money in your savings account is also incredibly liquid because you can easily withdraw it at the bank or ATM. The only drawback is that some savings accounts charge a fee if you make more than six withdrawals a month. Liquidity gives you the flexibility you need to spend your savings, such as tapping your emergency fund for a big car repair or buying that TV you’ve saved up for when it goes on sale.
Investments are typically less liquid than savings; the amount of rigidity varies among asset and account types. Certain types of investment vehicles, like bonds, may have a fixed term that requires you to stay invested for a certain amount of time. Stocks and shares of many funds are more liquid in that they can be sold any time, though it usually takes three business days to get your money. And if you’re selling stock because you need the money for an emergency, you run the risk of having to sell at a loss. Tax-advantaged retirement accounts, which are types of investment accounts, are extremely inflexible; you usually can’t withdraw money before age 59 1/2 without incurring steep penalties. Finally, if you invest in things like collectibles or real estate, your money is locked up in those assets until you can find a buyer, which could take a lot of time and effort.
Risks involved
People usually think about risk when it comes to investing, but not savings. It’s true that putting money into savings is generally quite low-risk. As long as you keep savings in an FDIC-insured bank account, you’re protected even if the bank were to go under. That said, saving money comes with certain risks, too. For example, if you only keep money in a traditional savings account without investing some of it, you run the risk that it won’t grow enough to keep up with inflation, leaving you with a lot less spending power in retirement. There’s also the risk associated with variable interest rates. If your bank drops interest rates, the return you’re earning on your savings will drop as well.
With investing, there’s always the risk that you could lose money if the value of your assets drops below what you paid for them. Business risk is the potential for a stock to lose value due to financial or management issues with the company. Geopolitical risk comes into play when things like war, terrorism, and trade relations impact the economy. And overall market volatility can cause the value of your portfolio to fluctuate. One way investors can manage these investment risks is by diversifying their portfolios. Diversification reduces risk by spreading the holdings in your investment portfolio across different asset classes like stocks, bonds, and funds. If one of your investments loses value, others may hold steady or even grow.
When to save your money
How do you decide when you should be saving vs. investing? Consider what you’re trying to achieve. Saving is well-suited to funding things you want within a few years and protecting your financial well-being when life throws you a curveball.
Financial goals: If there’s a large purchase you want to make in five years or less, saving for it makes sense. That’s too short a time to be confident that investments will grow, but not so long a timeframe that inflation is likely to seriously erode your purchasing power.
Emergency funds: If your dog needed emergency surgery tomorrow, could you pay for it without going into credit card debt? What about if you were laid off; how long could you cover your basic living expenses before your bank account was empty? These kinds of scenarios are exactly what an emergency fund is for. Putting aside money to cover unexpected expenses is one of the primary uses for a savings account.
If you want to save up more, look for ways to spend less. From sticking to a budget to reducing discretionary spending to lowering your bills, reducing how much money you spend increases how much money you can put into your savings.
Places you can park your cash and save
When you’re setting money aside for an emergency fund or savings goal, you can put it to work earning interest so your savings grow faster. There are several different kinds of deposit accounts where you can store your savings, and they vary in the details of potential interest rates, liquidity, minimum balances, and fees.
Traditional savings account: A basic savings account usually offers a pretty low interest rate; the average APY (annual percentage yield) was 0.45% as of May 2024. But there are often low or no minimum balances or fees, making them accessible if you’re just getting started with saving.
High-yield savings account: This type of account functions just like a traditional savings account, but offers much higher interest rates. At the same time, many require you to maintain a minimum balance and might charge account maintenance fees, which can eat into your returns. There’s often a minimum opening balance, too, so you’ll need to already have some funds accumulated before you can open an account.
Money market account: If you want higher rates and more liquidity, money market accounts can be a good place to keep your savings. Their interest rates are usually close to high-yield savings accounts, and, unlike savings accounts, they come with a limited number of checks and debit transactions a month. That makes it even easier to spend your money when you want to. Be aware that minimum balances and fees are common with these accounts.
Certificate of deposit (CD): Savings and money market accounts offer variable interest rates, so they could go up or down at any time. CDs, on the other hand, give you a fixed interest rate for a set term, usually between six months and six years. CDs often have interest rates as good as or better than high-yield savings accounts, but the trade-off is a lack of liquidity. If you withdraw your money before the term is over, you’ll generally lose some of the interest you’ve earned.
When to invest your money
Are you many years, or even decades, away from retirement, sending your kids to college, or putting a down payment on the house of your dreams? Do you have an emergency fund and enough money in savings for your short-term needs? Have you paid down any high interest debt? If so, it may be time to start investing your money. Investing is most likely to help you reach longer-term goals: things for which you need to build up a large amount of money, but you won’t need it any time soon. Consider investing when:
You don’t need the money within the next five years: Keeping your money in investments for at least five or ten years may lead to better returns in the end. Long-term investing is the idea that you hang onto assets long enough to ride out the inevitable ups and downs of the stock market.
Your employer offers 401(k) matching: Many employers will match your contributions dollar for dollar up to a certain percentage of your salary. It’s like free money for your retirement account. If your financial situation allows, invest at least as much as your employer will match so your retirement account grows more quickly.
You want tax advantages for retirement investments: The money you put into 401(k)s and traditional IRAs is pre-tax, meaning you don’t pay income tax until you withdraw it in retirement. Your contributions now are subtracted from your taxable income when you file your return, reducing your current tax burden.
Saving vs. investing: strike the balance you need for financial security
Saving and investing aren’t mutually exclusive. Understanding how to use both strategies empowers you to work toward your goals in the short term and far-off future using the right types of accounts for what you want to achieve. Something saving and investing have in common: the sooner you start, the more time your money has to grow. Start finding your balance today.
Investing made easy.
Start today with any dollar amount.